"The first time her laughter unfurled its wings in the wind, we knew that the world would never be the same"
- Brian Andreas

Saturday, January 26, 2013

Non-Fiction Reading Response


My reading response is on "Why You Truly Never Leave High School" by Jennifer Senior. The article talks about how the human brain changes and develops at different times of our life. The article specifically talks about how the person you are at 16 is about the same person that you are going to be the rest of your life. The article starts out by talking about a high school reunion and how at the reunion the author realized that the kids that she went to high school with, were kind-of the same people as they were when she knew them in high school. The article then continues to talk about brain development in teens and the way that the brain changes throughout their life, and how the brain will end up staying about the same throughout their life after 16. The article continues by talking about teenagers that are achieving a lot at a young age where a lot of the world is against you. The article concluded to talk about the specific people that she knew at her reunion and how the people that had not changed, and how she connected to them over Facebook.

This article really wants you to reflect on who you are as a person. A really thought provoking quote that I found in the article was: "In adolescence, the brain is buzzing with more dopamine activity than at any other time in the human life cycle, so everything an adolescent does - everything an adolescent feels- is just a little bit more intense and you can never get back to that intensity." This almost justifies teenagers being over dramatic and feeling way too intense about something that is very small thing to other people. I think that it explains to kids younger than16 that the things that they do really stick with them for the res of their life, but the article isn't about changing your life at 16 and making sure that you are the best you could possibly be. It's about who you truly are at 16 and how that affects you later in life. Your brain’s development from ages 0-3 is what scientists normally study to learn brain and development patterns but recent studies show that a 16 year olds brain development is a significant as it is ages 0-3. "For years, we had almost a religious belief that all systems developed in the same way which meant what happened from zero to three really mattered, but whatever happened thereafter was merely tweaking."

I feel like Jennifer Senior  wanted the readers older then 16 to think about who they are and how high school affected that. The article isn't biased, there wasn't a way to clearly go against it, it had the correct facts which is why it is such a good article. The article starts off with an anecdote and I think that because she started and ended with the same anecdote ( she finished the story in the end) the article tied together and you really understood what Jennifer Senior wanted everyone to think, she wanted them to think about where they are as a person and how they got there. Even though I am younger then sixteen I do feel like this article impacted my life greatly, it has made me think about what I'm doing with my life and why I'm doing the things I am.

Overall I loved this article because it connected to my life in so many different ways. I am going to high school very soon so the article made me think about who I am as a student and what I am doing with my life as a student, and it also connected to my life because so many of my moms friends talk about who they were in high school and so much of the time it matches who they are now. I am going to be sixteen sooner then I think that I am, so I believe that  I need to pick up my act and then I can really go far and do well

Thursday, January 17, 2013

response to a response


Found on Goodreads.com  http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/180373889

"The Fault in Our Stars currently has a rating of 4.74 on Goodreads, almost everyone I know has given it 5 stars, therefore I'm certain no one would want to read my sour musings, except me and maybe a couple of other like-minded and unimpressed.

What I'd love to know is this - what makes a writer undertake the topic of cancer? So much has already been written about it, so many Lifetime movies filmed, so many tears shed. It literally has been done to death. What new did John Green have to bring to the cancer table?

The way I see it, nothing. Having your terminally sick characters be ironic about their illnesses and swap cancer jokes isn't groundbreaking.

The Fault in Our Stars isn't a bad book, but it's a standard cancer book, and, sadly, a standard John Green book, with standardJohn Green humor and standard John Green characters speaking in the very same John Green voice. 

You have a witty and intelligent protagonist (this time 2, Hazel and Augustus - a female and male versions of Miles/Quentin/Colin), a funny, slightly pathetic sidekick (Isaac - another version of Hassan/Chip/Marcus), a mysterious, unhinged girl, Gus's dead ex (Alaska/Margo clone), and, of course, the signature ROAD TRIP. I can't help but recognize these people and this plot, I've read all of Green's novels.

I understand why so many readers would have such an emotional response to the book. Nothing will get the ladies crying quicker than a kid dying of cancer. Add in some long farewells, painkillers, eulogies and funerals - you can collect buckets of tears. But, IMO, here Green aims for the most obvious, the most easily accessible emotions, for the most typical "life lessons." And for all Green's attempts to be subversive and to make fun of "cancer cliches" - inspirational quotes, heroic cancer survivors, etc. he ended up writing about exactly the same things. 

Frankly, I think The Fault in Our Stars is Green's weakest work to date, weaker even than half-baked Zombicorns. Because this, unlike his earlier works, feels commercial and intentionally tearjerky and insincere. It will probably sell the most copies."


SPOILERS IN RESPONSE 


Overall " The Fault In Our Stars" was my favorite book, ever. Tatiana brought up some really valid points but she also said many things that I dont believe are true.

 
the "The Fault In Our Stars" is about a girl who has cancer, and her story of falling in love with a boy who she believed did not have cancer. Hazel and Augustus both fell in love with a book, and the book did not have an ending so they decided to travel to meet the author. While they were on their trip Hazel found out that Augustus has a serious amount of cancer that is terminal. They spend the rest of the book dealing with his cancer and later his death.

Tatiana wrote in the first paragraph her problems with John Green writing about cancer, "What I'd love to know is this - what makes a writer undertake the topic of cancer? So much has already been written about it, so many Lifetime movies filmed, so many tears shed. It literally has been done to death. What new did John Green have to bring to the cancer table? The way I see it, nothing. Having your terminally sick characters be ironic about their illnesses and swap cancer jokes isn't groundbreaking." 

 The way I see it, John was writing a love story for everyone. For the parents that need a little hope in knowing that their kids care about them, and for the teenagers that want to read about falling in love in the worst situations, and fighting through. Even though the book's topic is not the most original it's so perfect and it is so perfectly written. Tatiana called it standard which it isn't all. A drunk author with a mental problem? A perfectly well character dying? The two awkward kids becoming best friends? those are the things that kept the book going. 

"Nothing will get the ladies crying quicker than a kid dying of cancer. Add in some long farewells, painkillers, eulogies and funerals - you can collect buckets of tears." When Tatiana said this I was furious, I was in tears because I wanted them to die together, no one likes death. Whether it is with cancer patients or  cats. I was mainly in tears because of how in love they were. It wasn't something small to them they belonged together and cancer ended that, and it's a shame. 

Overall I don't agree with Tatiana's response, because I loved the book. I would reccomend it to anyone and everyone.