"The first time her laughter unfurled its wings in the wind, we knew that the world would never be the same"
- Brian Andreas

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Romeo and Juliet vs. Twilight


Romeo and Juliet vs. Edward and Bella

“Three words, dear Romeo, and good night indeed.
 If that thy bent of love be honorable, 
Thy purpose marriage, send me word tomorrow, 
By one that I'll procure to come to thee,  
Where and what time thou wilt perform the rite;                             
And all my fortunes at thy foot I'll lay 
And follow thee my lord throughout the world.”
Juliet Romeo and Juliet 2.2 142-148

“And I couldn’t stop the gloom that engulfed me as I realized I didn’t know how long I would have to wait before I saw him again”
Bella Swan Twilight ch6 p. 111

While these quotes are from two very different characters and take place in very different situations, these quotes prove that even though Twilight and Romeo and Juliet are very different books they have similarities and so do the romances of the 1500’s and 2013.  Both couples react and treat each other in the same ways even though they are very different.

In 2006 when Twilight was first published it wasn't a popular book but  in  2010 it blew up and became very popular. Twilight is flatly a romance about a vampire and a human – Edward and Bella- the perfect “modern” couple, but their relationship continuously reminded me of Romeo and Juliet even though their relationship lasted more than three days and not many were killed. because  In the short three days that Romeo and Juliet were together “they were in love”.

To Romeo it was all about sex. there's not a better way to put it, he wanted to have sex with Rosaline but she was waiting, so  Romeo swears his love to Juliet and eventually gets what he wants, sex. But men of this age are the same, so why does Edward keep himself from having sex with Bella? Because they aren’t a normal couple hes a vampire. So yes while I can't compare them because Twilight is part sy-fi so Twilight doesn’t have the “modern” couple but in the past few years smaller and smaller numbers of books have had a typical/normal couple. 

The big difference between Romeo and Juliet and Twilight is that in this century it’s a lot easier for couples to be accepted, and even if they went its so much easier to escape their families. The female characters are also very different, Bella is dependent on Edward and the things that he does for her while Juliet does love Romeo and obviously weren’t to great lengths to be with him, her entire life was not engulfed in him. she left questions with him and made him swear to her while Bella sat in a chair and stared out of a window for a year when Edward left.

Romeo, Juliet, Edward and Bella are all “ teenagers in love” they all represent what kids my age are trying to find. They want someone to unconditionally love even if they don’t know what unconditional love means. Twilight and Romeo and Juliet proved to be different books even if they both had a romance aspect in them, they are just from two different time periods and that greatly affected the similatires and differences in the characters, plot and sense of the books. 

Thursday, April 18, 2013

reading response

Response to Wintergirls and the message that it talks about,

Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson is about two 18 year old girls, Cassie and Lia who are both dealing with anorexia, but right in the beginning of the book we see that cassie takes her life after her long battle with anorexia. both girls even though they aren't friends anymore they were both battling with the same thing. Lia (the main character) tries to come off as a normal teenager and like she isn't carrying the weight of the world on her shoulders but because she is going through so much it is starting to become clear to others that she needs help.  Because the book is from her perspective we can see whats going on when she is making choices about eating food or throwing food up.

the messages Wintergirls talks about,

the book doesn't galm up anorexia at all, it doesn't make it seem plesurable at all, all throughout the book we can see that Lia has a problem, but as a reader we are only reading from her side so we start seeing where she's coming from and we almost start to agree with what she's doing, but once again we realize that Lia really does have a problem all throughout the book and she tries to deal with it but it is a mental problem.

this book really opened my mind to what happens when a person is anorexic or has a different type of mental problem. To lia not eating or eating as little as possible didn't phase her as hurting her body as readers we can tell. Wintergirls puts the reader in this awkward situation where the reader gets lost in Lia's character but then remembers that she insn't sane.